Home Topics Blogs list Vocabularynew
Top Blogs
Popular Tags

0
Relatives: identifying and non-identifying clauses
Blog »Grammar

Some relative clauses 'identify' nouns. They tell us which person or thing is meant.

  • What's the name of the tall man who just came in?
  • Whose is the car that's parked outside?
    (that's parked outside tells the hearer which car is meant: it identifies the car)


Other relative clauses do not identify. They tell us more about a person or thing that is already identified.

  • This is Ms Rogers, whom you met last year
    (whom you met last year does not tell us which woman is meant: we already know that it is Ms Rogers.)
  • Have you seen my new car, which I bought last week? (which I bought last week does not tell us which car is meant: we already know that it is 'my new car'.)


Non-identifying clauses are separated from the rest of the sentence bycommas (, ,). Identifying clauses do not have commas. Compare:

 

  • The woman who does my hair has moved to another hairdresser's.
  • Dorothy, who does my hair, has moved to another hairdresser's.


We only use that in identifying clauses. And we can only leave out the object in identifying clauses. Compare:

  • The whisky (that) you drank last night cost £15 a bottle.
  • I gave him a large glass of whisky, which he drank at once.
    (NOT ... whisky, that he drank ...) (NOT .. . whisky, he drank . . .)

Whom is unusual in identifying clauses. Compare:

  • The man (that) my daughter wants to marry has been divorced twice.
  • Max Harrison, whom my daughter wants to marry, has been divorced twice.


Non-identifying clauses are unusual in an informal style.


Share/Bookmark
Vera, 526 days ago 0
Comments
Home | Contacts | WordSteps.com - Enrich your Vocabulary
© 2008-2012 RapidSteps.com